No punitives for unseaworthiness

by Matthew H. Ammerman on March 1st, 2017

This is old news. But it is a follow-up to a previous post reporting on the panel opinion in McBride.

In an opinion issued on September 25, 2014, and penned by Judge W. Eugene Davis, the en banc Fifth Circuit holds that punitive damages are not available in a seaman's claim for unseaworthiness. McBride v. Estis Well Serv., L.L.C., 768 F.3d 381 (5th Cir. 2014)(en banc).

An unseaworthiness claim, which arises under general maritime law, is a claim that the vessel owner failed to furnish a vessel and appurtenances reasonably fit for their intended use.

In McBride, the en banc 5th Circuit reasoned that the U.S. Supreme Court's 1990 holding in Miles -- that a seaman's survivor may not recover non-pecuniary loss-of-society damages -- extended to a claim for punitive damages by both an injured and deceased seaman's survivor. Pecuniary losses in this context are money damages to compensate the plaintiff for "'actual loss" instead of damages fulfilling a punitive purpose.

This issue arises because in 2009 the Supreme Court reversed the Fifth Circuit and held that punitive damages were available for an employer's willful and wanton failure to pay maintenance and cure to a seaman. A maintenance-and-cure claim also arises under general maritime law, and, so the reasoning went, punitive damages should be available for an unseaworthiness claim as well.

The Fifth Circuit says no dice. The Supreme Court, when holding that punitive damages were available for egregious denial of maintenance and cure, clearly states the uniformity principle of Miles is sound. The limitation on non-pecuniary damages derived from FELA and incorporated into the Jones Act precludes punitive damages arising from a general maritime law claim of unseaworthiness.




Posted in Seamen    Tagged with punitive damages, unseaworthiness, mcbride, 5th Circuit

Search

Subscribe

follow on
Tags

11th circuit 5th Circuit 905(b) 9th circuit ALJ Aggravation Rule Amclyde Average weekly wage Bienvenu Boroski CMS Churchill Contribution Cowart Credit Intoxication defense L-MSA LHWCA discovery LHWCA Longshore Report of Injury Longshore situs Longshore Maintenance and cure New Orleans Depot OCSLA OPA Oil Pollution Act Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act Permanent total disability Roberts Section 10(a) Section 10(c) Section 20 Presumption Section 33(g) Section 7 Medical Section 7 Stroke Supreme Court Testbank Townsend Tracy Valladolid actually incurred additional insured adjoining area change of physician compensation container repair disability doiron dollar-for-dollar dr. seidemann eggshell skull exclusion extraterritorial general maritime law hearing loss herron factors indemnity intervening cause jones act joseph tracy last responsible employer rule liability MSA longshore act longshore status manderson maritime contract maritime punitive damages master service agreement maximum compensation rate mcbride v. estis mcbride medical expenses naquin non-pecuniary damages occupational disease outer continental shelf pai or incurred paid or incurred pecuniary damages percentage of responsibility presumption punitive damages ramos rate rebuttal recreational vessel seaman status seaman situs special weight status substantial nexus transitory maritime worker unseaworthiness vessel negligence vessel status voluntary retirement winchester test winchester zepeda mixed-use facility zepeda